| Description: Alternate version of
Russell's definition of a description binder, which
can be read as "the unique 𝑥 such that 𝜑", where 𝜑
ordinarily contains 𝑥 as a free variable. Our definition
is
meaningful only when there is exactly one 𝑥 such that 𝜑 is true
(see aiotaval 48370); otherwise, it is not a set (see aiotaexb 48364), or even
more concrete, it is the universe V (see aiotavb 48365). Since this
is an alternative for df-iota 6512, we call this symbol ℩'
alternate iota in the following.
The advantage of this definition is the clear distinguishability of the
defined and undefined cases: the alternate iota over a wff is defined
iff it is a set (see aiotaexb 48364). With the original definition,
there
is no corresponding theorem (∃!𝑥𝜑 ↔ (℩𝑥𝜑) ≠ ∅),
because ∅ can be a valid unique set
satisfying a wff (see, for
example, iota0def 48313). Only the right to left implication would
hold,
see (negated) iotanul 6537. See also aiotaexim 48373 which requires sethood
instead of not being empty. For defined cases, however, both
definitions df-iota 6512 and df-aiota 48360 are equivalent, see
reuaiotaiota 48363. (Proposed by BJ, 13-Aug-2022.)
(Contributed by AV,
24-Aug-2022.) |