Theorem nregmodel 45444

Description: The Axiom of Regularity ax-reg 9507 is false in the permutation model defined from 𝐹. Since the other axioms of ZFC hold in all permutation models (permaxext 45432 through permac8prim 45441), we can conclude that Regularity does not follow from those axioms, assuming ZFC is consistent. (If we could prove Regularity from the other axioms, we could prove it in the permutation model and thus obtain a contradiction with this theorem.) Since we also know that Regularity is consistent with the other axioms (wfaxext 45420 through wfac8prim 45429), Regularity is neither provable nor disprovable from the other axioms; i.e., it is independent of them. (Contributed by Eric Schmidt, 16-Nov-2025.)

Hypotheses

Ref	Expression
nregmodel.1	⊢ 𝐹 = (( I ↾ (V ∖ {∅, {∅}})) ∪ {⟨∅, {∅}⟩, ⟨{∅}, ∅⟩})
nregmodel.2	⊢ 𝑅 = (◡𝐹 ∘ E )

Assertion

Ref	Expression
nregmodel	⊢ ¬ ∀𝑥(∃𝑦 𝑦𝑅𝑥 → ∃𝑦(𝑦𝑅𝑥 ∧ ∀𝑧(𝑧𝑅𝑦 → ¬ 𝑧𝑅𝑥)))

Distinct variable groups:   𝑥,𝑦,𝑧   𝑥,𝑅

Allowed substitution hints:   𝑅(𝑦,𝑧)   𝐹(𝑥,𝑦,𝑧)

Proof of Theorem nregmodel

Step	Hyp	Ref	Expression
1		0ex 5243	. . 3 ⊢ ∅ ∈ V
2	1	snid 4607	. 2 ⊢ ∅ ∈ {∅}
3		eleq1 2825	. . . . 5 ⊢ (𝑦 = ∅ → (𝑦 ∈ {∅} ↔ ∅ ∈ {∅}))
4	1, 3, 2	ceqsexv2d 3480	. . . 4 ⊢ ∃𝑦 𝑦 ∈ {∅}
5		breq2 5090	. . . . . . . 8 ⊢ (𝑥 = ∅ → (𝑦𝑅𝑥 ↔ 𝑦𝑅∅))
6		nregmodel.1	. . . . . . . . 9 ⊢ 𝐹 = (( I ↾ (V ∖ {∅, {∅}})) ∪ {⟨∅, {∅}⟩, ⟨{∅}, ∅⟩})
7		nregmodel.2	. . . . . . . . 9 ⊢ 𝑅 = (◡𝐹 ∘ E )
8	6, 7	nregmodellem 45443	. . . . . . . 8 ⊢ (𝑦𝑅∅ ↔ 𝑦 ∈ {∅})
9	5, 8	bitrdi 287	. . . . . . 7 ⊢ (𝑥 = ∅ → (𝑦𝑅𝑥 ↔ 𝑦 ∈ {∅}))
10	9	exbidv 1923	. . . . . 6 ⊢ (𝑥 = ∅ → (∃𝑦 𝑦𝑅𝑥 ↔ ∃𝑦 𝑦 ∈ {∅}))
11		breq2 5090	. . . . . . . . . . . 12 ⊢ (𝑥 = ∅ → (𝑧𝑅𝑥 ↔ 𝑧𝑅∅))
12	6, 7	nregmodellem 45443	. . . . . . . . . . . 12 ⊢ (𝑧𝑅∅ ↔ 𝑧 ∈ {∅})
13	11, 12	bitrdi 287	. . . . . . . . . . 11 ⊢ (𝑥 = ∅ → (𝑧𝑅𝑥 ↔ 𝑧 ∈ {∅}))
14	13	notbid 318	. . . . . . . . . 10 ⊢ (𝑥 = ∅ → (¬ 𝑧𝑅𝑥 ↔ ¬ 𝑧 ∈ {∅}))
15	14	imbi2d 340	. . . . . . . . 9 ⊢ (𝑥 = ∅ → ((𝑧𝑅𝑦 → ¬ 𝑧𝑅𝑥) ↔ (𝑧𝑅𝑦 → ¬ 𝑧 ∈ {∅})))
16	15	albidv 1922	. . . . . . . 8 ⊢ (𝑥 = ∅ → (∀𝑧(𝑧𝑅𝑦 → ¬ 𝑧𝑅𝑥) ↔ ∀𝑧(𝑧𝑅𝑦 → ¬ 𝑧 ∈ {∅})))
17	9, 16	anbi12d 633	. . . . . . 7 ⊢ (𝑥 = ∅ → ((𝑦𝑅𝑥 ∧ ∀𝑧(𝑧𝑅𝑦 → ¬ 𝑧𝑅𝑥)) ↔ (𝑦 ∈ {∅} ∧ ∀𝑧(𝑧𝑅𝑦 → ¬ 𝑧 ∈ {∅}))))
18	17	exbidv 1923	. . . . . 6 ⊢ (𝑥 = ∅ → (∃𝑦(𝑦𝑅𝑥 ∧ ∀𝑧(𝑧𝑅𝑦 → ¬ 𝑧𝑅𝑥)) ↔ ∃𝑦(𝑦 ∈ {∅} ∧ ∀𝑧(𝑧𝑅𝑦 → ¬ 𝑧 ∈ {∅}))))
19	10, 18	imbi12d 344	. . . . 5 ⊢ (𝑥 = ∅ → ((∃𝑦 𝑦𝑅𝑥 → ∃𝑦(𝑦𝑅𝑥 ∧ ∀𝑧(𝑧𝑅𝑦 → ¬ 𝑧𝑅𝑥))) ↔ (∃𝑦 𝑦 ∈ {∅} → ∃𝑦(𝑦 ∈ {∅} ∧ ∀𝑧(𝑧𝑅𝑦 → ¬ 𝑧 ∈ {∅})))))
20	1, 19	spcv 3548	. . . 4 ⊢ (∀𝑥(∃𝑦 𝑦𝑅𝑥 → ∃𝑦(𝑦𝑅𝑥 ∧ ∀𝑧(𝑧𝑅𝑦 → ¬ 𝑧𝑅𝑥))) → (∃𝑦 𝑦 ∈ {∅} → ∃𝑦(𝑦 ∈ {∅} ∧ ∀𝑧(𝑧𝑅𝑦 → ¬ 𝑧 ∈ {∅}))))
21	4, 20	mpi 20	. . 3 ⊢ (∀𝑥(∃𝑦 𝑦𝑅𝑥 → ∃𝑦(𝑦𝑅𝑥 ∧ ∀𝑧(𝑧𝑅𝑦 → ¬ 𝑧𝑅𝑥))) → ∃𝑦(𝑦 ∈ {∅} ∧ ∀𝑧(𝑧𝑅𝑦 → ¬ 𝑧 ∈ {∅})))
22		df-ral 3053	. . . . 5 ⊢ (∀𝑧 ∈ {∅} ¬ 𝑧 ∈ {∅} ↔ ∀𝑧(𝑧 ∈ {∅} → ¬ 𝑧 ∈ {∅}))
23		breq2 5090	. . . . . . . . 9 ⊢ (𝑦 = ∅ → (𝑧𝑅𝑦 ↔ 𝑧𝑅∅))
24	23, 12	bitrdi 287	. . . . . . . 8 ⊢ (𝑦 = ∅ → (𝑧𝑅𝑦 ↔ 𝑧 ∈ {∅}))
25	24	imbi1d 341	. . . . . . 7 ⊢ (𝑦 = ∅ → ((𝑧𝑅𝑦 → ¬ 𝑧 ∈ {∅}) ↔ (𝑧 ∈ {∅} → ¬ 𝑧 ∈ {∅})))
26	25	albidv 1922	. . . . . 6 ⊢ (𝑦 = ∅ → (∀𝑧(𝑧𝑅𝑦 → ¬ 𝑧 ∈ {∅}) ↔ ∀𝑧(𝑧 ∈ {∅} → ¬ 𝑧 ∈ {∅})))
27	1, 26	rexsn 4627	. . . . 5 ⊢ (∃𝑦 ∈ {∅}∀𝑧(𝑧𝑅𝑦 → ¬ 𝑧 ∈ {∅}) ↔ ∀𝑧(𝑧 ∈ {∅} → ¬ 𝑧 ∈ {∅}))
28		df-rex 3063	. . . . 5 ⊢ (∃𝑦 ∈ {∅}∀𝑧(𝑧𝑅𝑦 → ¬ 𝑧 ∈ {∅}) ↔ ∃𝑦(𝑦 ∈ {∅} ∧ ∀𝑧(𝑧𝑅𝑦 → ¬ 𝑧 ∈ {∅})))
29	22, 27, 28	3bitr2ri 300	. . . 4 ⊢ (∃𝑦(𝑦 ∈ {∅} ∧ ∀𝑧(𝑧𝑅𝑦 → ¬ 𝑧 ∈ {∅})) ↔ ∀𝑧 ∈ {∅} ¬ 𝑧 ∈ {∅})
30		eleq1 2825	. . . . . 6 ⊢ (𝑧 = ∅ → (𝑧 ∈ {∅} ↔ ∅ ∈ {∅}))
31	30	notbid 318	. . . . 5 ⊢ (𝑧 = ∅ → (¬ 𝑧 ∈ {∅} ↔ ¬ ∅ ∈ {∅}))
32	1, 31	ralsn 4626	. . . 4 ⊢ (∀𝑧 ∈ {∅} ¬ 𝑧 ∈ {∅} ↔ ¬ ∅ ∈ {∅})
33	29, 32	bitri 275	. . 3 ⊢ (∃𝑦(𝑦 ∈ {∅} ∧ ∀𝑧(𝑧𝑅𝑦 → ¬ 𝑧 ∈ {∅})) ↔ ¬ ∅ ∈ {∅})
34	21, 33	sylib 218	. 2 ⊢ (∀𝑥(∃𝑦 𝑦𝑅𝑥 → ∃𝑦(𝑦𝑅𝑥 ∧ ∀𝑧(𝑧𝑅𝑦 → ¬ 𝑧𝑅𝑥))) → ¬ ∅ ∈ {∅})
35	2, 34	mt2 200	1 ⊢ ¬ ∀𝑥(∃𝑦 𝑦𝑅𝑥 → ∃𝑦(𝑦𝑅𝑥 ∧ ∀𝑧(𝑧𝑅𝑦 → ¬ 𝑧𝑅𝑥)))

Syntax hints:  ¬ wn 3   → wi 4   ∧ wa 395  ∀wal 1540   = wceq 1542  ∃wex 1781   ∈ wcel 2114  ∀wral 3052  ∃wrex 3062  Vcvv 3430   ∖ cdif 3887   ∪ cun 3888  ∅c0 4274  {csn 4568  {cpr 4570  ⟨cop 4574   class class class wbr 5086   I cid 5525   E cep 5530  ^◡ccnv 5630   ↾ cres 5633   ∘ ccom 5635

This theorem was proved from axioms:  ax-mp 5  ax-1 6  ax-2 7  ax-3 8  ax-gen 1797  ax-4 1811  ax-5 1912  ax-6 1969  ax-7 2010  ax-8 2116  ax-9 2124  ax-10 2147  ax-11 2163  ax-12 2185  ax-ext 2709  ax-sep 5232  ax-nul 5242  ax-pr 5376

This theorem depends on definitions:  df-bi 207  df-an 396  df-or 849  df-3an 1089  df-tru 1545  df-fal 1555  df-ex 1782  df-nf 1786  df-sb 2069  df-mo 2540  df-eu 2570  df-clab 2716  df-cleq 2729  df-clel 2812  df-nfc 2886  df-ne 2934  df-ral 3053  df-rex 3063  df-reu 3344  df-rab 3391  df-v 3432  df-sbc 3730  df-csb 3839  df-dif 3893  df-un 3895  df-in 3897  df-ss 3907  df-nul 4275  df-if 4468  df-sn 4569  df-pr 4571  df-op 4575  df-uni 4852  df-br 5087  df-opab 5149  df-mpt 5168  df-id 5526  df-eprel 5531  df-xp 5637  df-rel 5638  df-cnv 5639  df-co 5640  df-dm 5641  df-rn 5642  df-res 5643  df-ima 5644  df-iota 6455  df-fun 6501  df-fn 6502  df-f 6503  df-f1 6504  df-fo 6505  df-f1o 6506  df-fv 6507

This theorem is referenced by: (None)