Theorem List for Intuitionistic Logic Explorer - 601-700   *Has distinct variable
 group(s)
| Type | Label | Description | 
| Statement | 
|   | 
| Theorem | pm5.1 601 | 
Two propositions are equivalent if they are both true.  Theorem *5.1 of
     [WhiteheadRussell] p. 123. 
(Contributed by NM, 21-May-1994.)
 | 
                      | 
|   | 
| Theorem | pm3.43 602 | 
Theorem *3.43 (Comp) of [WhiteheadRussell] p. 113.  (Contributed
by NM,
     3-Jan-2005.)  (Revised by NM, 27-Nov-2013.)
 | 
                             
           | 
|   | 
| Theorem | jcab 603 | 
Distributive law for implication over conjunction.  Compare Theorem *4.76
     of [WhiteheadRussell] p. 121. 
(Contributed by NM, 3-Apr-1994.)  (Proof
     shortened by Wolf Lammen, 27-Nov-2013.)
 | 
                                        | 
|   | 
| Theorem | pm4.76 604 | 
Theorem *4.76 of [WhiteheadRussell] p.
121.  (Contributed by NM,
     3-Jan-2005.)
 | 
                                        | 
|   | 
| Theorem | pm4.38 605 | 
Theorem *4.38 of [WhiteheadRussell] p.
118.  (Contributed by NM,
     3-Jan-2005.)
 | 
                                              | 
|   | 
| Theorem | bi2anan9 606 | 
Deduction joining two equivalences to form equivalence of conjunctions.
       (Contributed by NM, 31-Jul-1995.)
 | 
                                                                              | 
|   | 
| Theorem | bi2anan9r 607 | 
Deduction joining two equivalences to form equivalence of conjunctions.
       (Contributed by NM, 19-Feb-1996.)
 | 
                                                      
                        | 
|   | 
| Theorem | bi2bian9 608 | 
Deduction joining two biconditionals with different antecedents.
       (Contributed by NM, 12-May-2004.)
 | 
                                                                              | 
|   | 
| Theorem | pm5.33 609 | 
Theorem *5.33 of [WhiteheadRussell] p.
125.  (Contributed by NM,
     3-Jan-2005.)
 | 
                           
             | 
|   | 
| Theorem | pm5.36 610 | 
Theorem *5.36 of [WhiteheadRussell] p.
125.  (Contributed by NM,
     3-Jan-2005.)
 | 
                                  | 
|   | 
| Theorem | bianabs 611 | 
Absorb a hypothesis into the second member of a biconditional.
       (Contributed by FL, 15-Feb-2007.)
 | 
                                            | 
|   | 
| Theorem | biadani 612 | 
An implication implies to the equivalence of some implied equivalence
       and some other equivalence involving a conjunction.  (Contributed by BJ,
       4-Mar-2023.)
 | 
                                                  | 
|   | 
| Theorem | biadanii 613 | 
Inference associated with biadani 612.  Add a conjunction to an
       equivalence.  (Contributed by Jeff Madsen, 20-Jun-2011.)  (Proof
       shortened by BJ, 4-Mar-2023.)
 | 
                                                      | 
|   | 
| Theorem | biadanid 614 | 
Deduction associated with biadani 612.  Add a conjunction to an
       equivalence.  (Contributed by Thierry Arnoux, 16-Jun-2024.)
 | 
                                                                        | 
|   | 
| 1.2.5  Logical negation
 (intuitionistic)
 | 
|   | 
| Axiom | ax-in1 615 | 
'Not' introduction.  One of the axioms of propositional logic.
     (Contributed by Mario Carneiro, 31-Jan-2015.)  Use its alias pm2.01 617
     instead.  (New usage is discouraged.)
 | 
            
        | 
|   | 
| Axiom | ax-in2 616 | 
'Not' elimination.  One of the axioms of propositional logic.
     (Contributed by Mario Carneiro, 31-Jan-2015.)
 | 
                  | 
|   | 
| Theorem | pm2.01 617 | 
Reductio ad absurdum.  Theorem *2.01 of [WhiteheadRussell] p. 100.  This
     is valid intuitionistically (in the terminology of Section 1.2 of [Bauer]
     p. 482 it is a proof of negation not a proof by contradiction); compare
     with pm2.18dc 856 which only holds for some propositions.  Also
called weak
     Clavius law.  (Contributed by Mario Carneiro, 12-May-2015.)
 | 
            
        | 
|   | 
| Theorem | pm2.21 618 | 
From a wff and its negation, anything is true.  Theorem *2.21 of
     [WhiteheadRussell] p. 104.  Also
called the Duns Scotus law.  (Contributed
     by Mario Carneiro, 12-May-2015.)
 | 
                  | 
|   | 
| Theorem | pm2.01d 619 | 
Deduction based on reductio ad absurdum.  (Contributed by NM,
       18-Aug-1993.)  (Revised by Mario Carneiro, 31-Jan-2015.)
 | 
             
                       | 
|   | 
| Theorem | pm2.21d 620 | 
A contradiction implies anything.  Deduction from pm2.21 618.
       (Contributed by NM, 10-Feb-1996.)
 | 
                                  | 
|   | 
| Theorem | pm2.21dd 621 | 
A contradiction implies anything.  Deduction from pm2.21 618.
       (Contributed by Mario Carneiro, 9-Feb-2017.)
 | 
                        
                    | 
|   | 
| Theorem | pm2.24 622 | 
Theorem *2.24 of [WhiteheadRussell] p.
104.  (Contributed by NM,
     3-Jan-2005.)
 | 
             
     | 
|   | 
| Theorem | pm2.24d 623 | 
Deduction version of pm2.24 622.  (Contributed by NM, 30-Jan-2006.)
       (Revised by Mario Carneiro, 31-Jan-2015.)
 | 
                                  | 
|   | 
| Theorem | pm2.24i 624 | 
Inference version of pm2.24 622.  (Contributed by NM, 20-Aug-2001.)
       (Revised by Mario Carneiro, 31-Jan-2015.)
 | 
                      | 
|   | 
| Theorem | con2d 625 | 
A contraposition deduction.  (Contributed by NM, 19-Aug-1993.)  (Revised
       by NM, 12-Feb-2013.)
 | 
             
                        
     | 
|   | 
| Theorem | mt2d 626 | 
Modus tollens deduction.  (Contributed by NM, 4-Jul-1994.)
 | 
                                                    | 
|   | 
| Theorem | nsyl3 627 | 
A negated syllogism inference.  (Contributed by NM, 1-Dec-1995.)
       (Revised by NM, 13-Jun-2013.)
 | 
                                          
    | 
|   | 
| Theorem | con2i 628 | 
A contraposition inference.  (Contributed by NM, 5-Aug-1993.)  (Proof
       shortened by O'Cat, 28-Nov-2008.)  (Proof shortened by Wolf Lammen,
       13-Jun-2013.)
 | 
                              | 
|   | 
| Theorem | nsyl 629 | 
A negated syllogism inference.  (Contributed by NM, 31-Dec-1993.)
       (Proof shortened by Wolf Lammen, 2-Mar-2013.)
 | 
                                          
    | 
|   | 
| Theorem | notnot 630 | 
Double negation introduction.  Theorem *2.12 of [WhiteheadRussell] p. 101.
     The converse need not hold.  It holds exactly for stable propositions (by
     definition, see df-stab 832) and in particular for decidable propositions
     (see notnotrdc 844).  See also notnotnot 635.  (Contributed by NM,
     28-Dec-1992.)  (Proof shortened by Wolf Lammen, 2-Mar-2013.)
 | 
              | 
|   | 
| Theorem | notnotd 631 | 
Deduction associated with notnot 630 and notnoti 646.  (Contributed by
       Jarvin Udandy, 2-Sep-2016.)  Avoid biconditional.  (Revised by Wolf
       Lammen, 27-Mar-2021.)
 | 
                        
      | 
|   | 
| Theorem | con3d 632 | 
A contraposition deduction.  (Contributed by NM, 5-Aug-1993.)  (Revised
       by NM, 31-Jan-2015.)
 | 
                                          | 
|   | 
| Theorem | con3i 633 | 
A contraposition inference.  (Contributed by NM, 5-Aug-1993.)  (Proof
       shortened by Wolf Lammen, 20-Jun-2013.)
 | 
                        
      | 
|   | 
| Theorem | con3rr3 634 | 
Rotate through consequent right.  (Contributed by Wolf Lammen,
       3-Nov-2013.)
 | 
                                          | 
|   | 
| Theorem | notnotnot 635 | 
Triple negation is equivalent to negation.  (Contributed by Jim Kingdon,
     28-Jul-2018.)
 | 
                  | 
|   | 
| Theorem | con3dimp 636 | 
Variant of con3d 632 with importation.  (Contributed by Jonathan
Ben-Naim,
       3-Jun-2011.)
 | 
                                          | 
|   | 
| Theorem | pm2.01da 637 | 
Deduction based on reductio ad absurdum.  (Contributed by Mario
       Carneiro, 9-Feb-2017.)
 | 
              
                  
    | 
|   | 
| Theorem | pm3.2im 638 | 
In classical logic, this is just a restatement of pm3.2 139.  In
     intuitionistic logic, it still holds, but is weaker than pm3.2.
     (Contributed by Mario Carneiro, 12-May-2015.)
 | 
             
             | 
|   | 
| Theorem | expi 639 | 
An exportation inference.  (Contributed by NM, 5-Aug-1993.)  (Proof
       shortened by O'Cat, 28-Nov-2008.)
 | 
                                          | 
|   | 
| Theorem | pm2.65i 640 | 
Inference for proof by contradiction.  (Contributed by NM, 18-May-1994.)
       (Proof shortened by Wolf Lammen, 11-Sep-2013.)
 | 
                        
                | 
|   | 
| Theorem | mt2 641 | 
A rule similar to modus tollens.  (Contributed by NM, 19-Aug-1993.)
       (Proof shortened by Wolf Lammen, 10-Sep-2013.)
 | 
                                  | 
|   | 
| Theorem | biijust 642 | 
Theorem used to justify definition of intuitionistic biconditional
     df-bi 117.  (Contributed by NM, 24-Nov-2017.)
 | 
                                                                                              | 
|   | 
| Theorem | con3 643 | 
Contraposition.  Theorem *2.16 of [WhiteheadRussell] p. 103.  (Contributed
     by NM, 5-Aug-1993.)  (Proof shortened by Wolf Lammen, 13-Feb-2013.)
 | 
            
              | 
|   | 
| Theorem | con2 644 | 
Contraposition.  Theorem *2.03 of [WhiteheadRussell] p. 100.  (Contributed
     by NM, 5-Aug-1993.)  (Proof shortened by Wolf Lammen, 12-Feb-2013.)
 | 
                     
     | 
|   | 
| Theorem | mt2i 645 | 
Modus tollens inference.  (Contributed by NM, 26-Mar-1995.)  (Proof
       shortened by Wolf Lammen, 15-Sep-2012.)
 | 
                       
                       | 
|   | 
| Theorem | notnoti 646 | 
Infer double negation.  (Contributed by NM, 27-Feb-2008.)
 | 
               
   | 
|   | 
| Theorem | pm2.21i 647 | 
A contradiction implies anything.  Inference from pm2.21 618.
       (Contributed by NM, 16-Sep-1993.)  (Revised by Mario Carneiro,
       31-Jan-2015.)
 | 
                      | 
|   | 
| Theorem | pm2.24ii 648 | 
A contradiction implies anything.  Inference from pm2.24 622.
       (Contributed by NM, 27-Feb-2008.)
 | 
                          | 
|   | 
| Theorem | nsyld 649 | 
A negated syllogism deduction.  (Contributed by NM, 9-Apr-2005.)
 | 
             
                                            
       | 
|   | 
| Theorem | nsyli 650 | 
A negated syllogism inference.  (Contributed by NM, 3-May-1994.)
 | 
                              
                            | 
|   | 
| Theorem | jc 651 | 
Inference joining the consequents of two premises.  (Contributed by NM,
       5-Aug-1993.)
 | 
                                               
     | 
|   | 
| Theorem | jcn 652 | 
Theorem joining the consequents of two premises.  Theorem 8 of [Margaris]
     p. 60.  (Contributed by NM, 5-Aug-1993.)  (Proof shortened by Josh
     Purinton, 29-Dec-2000.)
 | 
             
             | 
|   | 
| Theorem | jcnd 653 | 
Deduction joining the consequents of two premises.  (Contributed by
       Glauco Siliprandi, 11-Dec-2019.)  (Proof shortened by Wolf Lammen,
       10-Apr-2024.)
 | 
                        
                  
          | 
|   | 
| Theorem | conax1 654 | 
Contrapositive of ax-1 6.  (Contributed by BJ, 28-Oct-2023.)
 | 
                    | 
|   | 
| Theorem | conax1k 655 | 
Weakening of conax1 654.  General instance of pm2.51 656 and of pm2.52 657.
     (Contributed by BJ, 28-Oct-2023.)
 | 
                     
     | 
|   | 
| Theorem | pm2.51 656 | 
Theorem *2.51 of [WhiteheadRussell] p.
107.  (Contributed by NM,
     3-Jan-2005.)
 | 
                     
     | 
|   | 
| Theorem | pm2.52 657 | 
Theorem *2.52 of [WhiteheadRussell] p.
107.  (Contributed by NM,
     3-Jan-2005.)  (Revised by Mario Carneiro, 31-Jan-2015.)
 | 
                     
       | 
|   | 
| Theorem | expt 658 | 
Exportation theorem pm3.3 261 (closed form of ex 115)
expressed with
     primitive connectives.  (Contributed by NM, 5-Aug-1993.)
 | 
            
                          | 
|   | 
| Theorem | jarl 659 | 
Elimination of a nested antecedent.  (Contributed by Wolf Lammen,
     10-May-2013.)
 | 
                              | 
|   | 
| Theorem | pm2.65 660 | 
Theorem *2.65 of [WhiteheadRussell] p.
107.  Proof by contradiction.
     Proofs, such as this one, which assume a proposition, here  , derive
     a contradiction, and therefore conclude    , are valid
     intuitionistically (and can be called "proof of negation", for
example by
     Section 1.2 of [Bauer] p. 482).  By
contrast, proofs which assume
        , derive a
contradiction, and conclude  , such as
     condandc 882, are only valid for decidable propositions. 
(Contributed by
     NM, 5-Aug-1993.)  (Proof shortened by Wolf Lammen, 8-Mar-2013.)
 | 
            
        
            | 
|   | 
| Theorem | pm2.65d 661 | 
Deduction for proof by contradiction.  (Contributed by NM, 26-Jun-1994.)
       (Proof shortened by Wolf Lammen, 26-May-2013.)
 | 
                                                          | 
|   | 
| Theorem | pm2.65da 662 | 
Deduction for proof by contradiction.  (Contributed by NM,
       12-Jun-2014.)
 | 
                                                          | 
|   | 
| Theorem | mto 663 | 
The rule of modus tollens.  (Contributed by NM, 19-Aug-1993.)  (Proof
       shortened by Wolf Lammen, 11-Sep-2013.)
 | 
                                  | 
|   | 
| Theorem | mtod 664 | 
Modus tollens deduction.  (Contributed by NM, 3-Apr-1994.)  (Proof
       shortened by Wolf Lammen, 11-Sep-2013.)
 | 
                                                    | 
|   | 
| Theorem | mtoi 665 | 
Modus tollens inference.  (Contributed by NM, 5-Jul-1994.)  (Proof
       shortened by Wolf Lammen, 15-Sep-2012.)
 | 
                       
                       | 
|   | 
| Theorem | mtand 666 | 
A modus tollens deduction.  (Contributed by Jeff Hankins,
       19-Aug-2009.)
 | 
                                                    | 
|   | 
| Theorem | notbi 667 | 
Equivalence property for negation.  Closed form.  (Contributed by BJ,
     27-Jan-2020.)
 | 
                          | 
|   | 
| Theorem | notbid 668 | 
Equivalence property for negation.  Deduction form.  (Contributed by NM,
       21-May-1994.)  (Revised by Mario Carneiro, 31-Jan-2015.)
 | 
                                          | 
|   | 
| Theorem | notbii 669 | 
Equivalence property for negation.  Inference form.  (Contributed by NM,
       5-Aug-1993.)  (Revised by Mario Carneiro, 31-Jan-2015.)
 | 
                              | 
|   | 
| Theorem | con2b 670 | 
Contraposition.  Bidirectional version of con2 644. 
(Contributed by NM,
     5-Aug-1993.)
 | 
                          | 
|   | 
| Theorem | mtbi 671 | 
An inference from a biconditional, related to modus tollens.
       (Contributed by NM, 15-Nov-1994.)  (Proof shortened by Wolf Lammen,
       25-Oct-2012.)
 | 
                                  | 
|   | 
| Theorem | mtbir 672 | 
An inference from a biconditional, related to modus tollens.
       (Contributed by NM, 15-Nov-1994.)  (Proof shortened by Wolf Lammen,
       14-Oct-2012.)
 | 
                                  | 
|   | 
| Theorem | mtbid 673 | 
A deduction from a biconditional, similar to modus tollens.
       (Contributed by NM, 26-Nov-1995.)
 | 
                                                    | 
|   | 
| Theorem | mtbird 674 | 
A deduction from a biconditional, similar to modus tollens.
       (Contributed by NM, 10-May-1994.)
 | 
                                                    | 
|   | 
| Theorem | mtbii 675 | 
An inference from a biconditional, similar to modus tollens.
       (Contributed by NM, 27-Nov-1995.)
 | 
                                              | 
|   | 
| Theorem | mtbiri 676 | 
An inference from a biconditional, similar to modus tollens.
       (Contributed by NM, 24-Aug-1995.)
 | 
                                              | 
|   | 
| Theorem | sylnib 677 | 
A mixed syllogism inference from an implication and a biconditional.
       (Contributed by Wolf Lammen, 16-Dec-2013.)
 | 
                                              | 
|   | 
| Theorem | sylnibr 678 | 
A mixed syllogism inference from an implication and a biconditional.
       Useful for substituting an consequent with a definition.  (Contributed
       by Wolf Lammen, 16-Dec-2013.)
 | 
                                              | 
|   | 
| Theorem | sylnbi 679 | 
A mixed syllogism inference from a biconditional and an implication.
       Useful for substituting an antecedent with a definition.  (Contributed
       by Wolf Lammen, 16-Dec-2013.)
 | 
                                              | 
|   | 
| Theorem | sylnbir 680 | 
A mixed syllogism inference from a biconditional and an implication.
       (Contributed by Wolf Lammen, 16-Dec-2013.)
 | 
                                              | 
|   | 
| Theorem | xchnxbi 681 | 
Replacement of a subexpression by an equivalent one.  (Contributed by
       Wolf Lammen, 27-Sep-2014.)
 | 
                                              | 
|   | 
| Theorem | xchnxbir 682 | 
Replacement of a subexpression by an equivalent one.  (Contributed by
       Wolf Lammen, 27-Sep-2014.)
 | 
                                              | 
|   | 
| Theorem | xchbinx 683 | 
Replacement of a subexpression by an equivalent one.  (Contributed by
       Wolf Lammen, 27-Sep-2014.)
 | 
                                              | 
|   | 
| Theorem | xchbinxr 684 | 
Replacement of a subexpression by an equivalent one.  (Contributed by
       Wolf Lammen, 27-Sep-2014.)
 | 
                                              | 
|   | 
| Theorem | mt2bi 685 | 
A false consequent falsifies an antecedent.  (Contributed by NM,
       19-Aug-1993.)  (Proof shortened by Wolf Lammen, 12-Nov-2012.)
 | 
                              | 
|   | 
| Theorem | mtt 686 | 
Modus-tollens-like theorem.  (Contributed by NM, 7-Apr-2001.)  (Revised by
     Mario Carneiro, 31-Jan-2015.)
 | 
                          | 
|   | 
| Theorem | annimim 687 | 
Express conjunction in terms of implication.  One direction of Theorem
     *4.61 of [WhiteheadRussell] p.
120.  The converse holds for decidable
     propositions, as can be seen at annimdc 939.  (Contributed by Jim Kingdon,
     24-Dec-2017.)
 | 
              
            | 
|   | 
| Theorem | pm4.65r 688 | 
One direction of Theorem *4.65 of [WhiteheadRussell] p. 120.  The converse
     holds in classical logic.  (Contributed by Jim Kingdon, 28-Jul-2018.)
 | 
                         
     | 
|   | 
| Theorem | imanim 689 | 
Express implication in terms of conjunction.  The converse only holds
     given a decidability condition; see imandc 890.  (Contributed by Jim
     Kingdon, 24-Dec-2017.)
 | 
            
              | 
|   | 
| Theorem | pm3.37 690 | 
Theorem *3.37 (Transp) of [WhiteheadRussell] p. 112.  (Contributed
by NM,
     3-Jan-2005.)
 | 
                               
       | 
|   | 
| Theorem | imnan 691 | 
Express implication in terms of conjunction.  (Contributed by NM,
     9-Apr-1994.)  (Revised by Mario Carneiro, 1-Feb-2015.)
 | 
                          | 
|   | 
| Theorem | imnani 692 | 
Express implication in terms of conjunction.  (Contributed by Mario
       Carneiro, 28-Sep-2015.)
 | 
                              | 
|   | 
| Theorem | nan 693 | 
Theorem to move a conjunct in and out of a negation.  (Contributed by NM,
     9-Nov-2003.)
 | 
                  
                    | 
|   | 
| Theorem | pm3.24 694 | 
Law of noncontradiction.  Theorem *3.24 of [WhiteheadRussell] p. 111 (who
     call it the "law of contradiction").  (Contributed by NM,
16-Sep-1993.)
     (Revised by Mario Carneiro, 2-Feb-2015.)
 | 
              | 
|   | 
| Theorem | pm4.15 695 | 
Theorem *4.15 of [WhiteheadRussell] p.
117.  (Contributed by NM,
     3-Jan-2005.)  (Proof shortened by Wolf Lammen, 18-Nov-2012.)
 | 
                               
       | 
|   | 
| Theorem | pm5.21 696 | 
Two propositions are equivalent if they are both false.  Theorem *5.21 of
     [WhiteheadRussell] p. 124. 
(Contributed by NM, 21-May-1994.)  (Revised by
     Mario Carneiro, 31-Jan-2015.)
 | 
                          | 
|   | 
| Theorem | pm5.21im 697 | 
Two propositions are equivalent if they are both false.  Closed form of
     2false 702.  Equivalent to a biimpr 130-like version of the xor-connective.
     (Contributed by Wolf Lammen, 13-May-2013.)  (Revised by Mario Carneiro,
     31-Jan-2015.)
 | 
                          | 
|   | 
| Theorem | nbn2 698 | 
The negation of a wff is equivalent to the wff's equivalence to falsehood.
     (Contributed by Juha Arpiainen, 19-Jan-2006.)  (Revised by Mario Carneiro,
     31-Jan-2015.)
 | 
                          | 
|   | 
| Theorem | bibif 699 | 
Transfer negation via an equivalence.  (Contributed by NM, 3-Oct-2007.)
     (Proof shortened by Wolf Lammen, 28-Jan-2013.)
 | 
                          | 
|   | 
| Theorem | nbn 700 | 
The negation of a wff is equivalent to the wff's equivalence to
       falsehood.  (Contributed by NM, 5-Aug-1993.)  (Proof shortened by Wolf
       Lammen, 3-Oct-2013.)
 | 
                              |